Gold IRA Blueprint|Silver vs Stocks

Silver vs Stock Market Comparison

Compare historical performance and see when silver outperformed stocks

Select Time Period to Compare

Silver IRA Blueprint

Silver vs S&P 500 • 10 Years

Generated April 27, 2026

Normalized Performance

Start = 100

Silver
S&P 500

Key Takeaways

  • Silver led this period, returning +387.0% vs +220.6% for stocks.
  • Silver cushioned the worst year better: 2021 (-13.4%) vs stocks 2022 (-19.4%).
  • Silver outperformed in 4/10 years (40%).

Why Diversify with Silver?

  • Silver has both monetary value and industrial demand (solar, EVs, electronics), providing dual growth drivers.
  • Physical silver is not correlated with traditional paper assets like stocks and bonds.
  • Silver offers a lower entry point than gold while maintaining precious metals portfolio benefits.

Did You Know?

Silver demand from solar panels and electric vehicles continues to grow exponentially.
Silver IRAs allow tax-advantaged retirement savings backed by physical precious metals.
Unlike stocks, silver has no counterparty risk—it cannot go bankrupt or default.
Limited Time Offer

Ready to Protect Your Retirement with Silver?

Join thousands of investors who have diversified their portfolios with precious metals. Get a free silver IRA kit with no obligation.

Get Your Free Silver IRA Kit

Scan for mobile

Diversification Tip

Many financial advisors suggest allocating 5-15% of your portfolio to precious metals as a hedge against inflation and market volatility. A Silver IRA allows you to hold physical silver in a tax-advantaged retirement account.

Sources: LBMA Silver Price, S&P Dow Jones Indices, Federal Reserve Economic Data

Silver IRA Blueprint

Performance Comparison

Updated Never

Normalized to 100 at start of period

Limited Time Offer

Ready to Protect Your Retirement with Silver?

Join thousands of investors who have diversified their portfolios with precious metals. Get a free silver IRA kit with no obligation.

Get Your Free Silver IRA Kit

Ideal for investors with $100k+ in retirement accounts

Performance Breakdown

Total Returns

Starting with $10,000

Silver

+387.0%

$48,700

S&P 500

+220.6%

$32,058

Silver Won!

Silver vs Stocks

Silver beat stocks in 4 of 10 years

Silver: 40%Stocks: 60%

Best Year

Silver Peak

2025

+148.2%

S&P 500 Peak

2019

+28.9%

Worst Year

Silver Low

2021

-13.4%

S&P 500 Low

2022

-19.4%

Market Prices

As of 2026-03

Silver (XAG/USD)

$74.90-20.15%

S&P 500

6,604-3.20%

Monthly data • Updates with chart

Key Insights from This Period

  • Silver provided better returns during this period, gaining 387.0% compared to stocks' 220.6%.
  • Silver showed higher volatility, which can mean greater profit potential but also higher risk during turbulent markets.
  • During the worst years, silver provided better protection, limiting losses to -13.4% vs stocks' -19.4%.
  • Both assets ended positive, with silver taking the lead.

When Did Silver Shine?

1980 Hunt Brothers Peak

Silver hit $49.45/oz as the Hunt Brothers attempted to corner the silver market

2011 Near $50

Silver reached $49.82/oz amid QE programs and inflation fears - highest since 1980

2020-2021 Reddit Squeeze

Silver surged past $28/oz as WallStreetBets retail investors targeted the metal

2024 Industrial Boom

Silver broke $93.80/oz on solar panel and EV battery demand

Normalized to 100: This chart sets both investments to start at 100% for easy comparison. This way you can see relative performance regardless of actual dollar amounts.

Line Direction: A line going up means that investment gained value. A line going down means it lost value.

Comparing Lines: When silver's line is above stocks, silver performed better during that period. The further apart the lines, the bigger the performance difference.

⚠️ Important: Historical performance doesn't guarantee future results. Past trends show what happened, not what will happen.

💡 Diversification Tip: Most financial advisors recommend holding 5-15% of your portfolio in precious metals for diversification. Silver often moves differently than stocks, providing balance during market volatility and protecting against inflation.

See How Silver Could Protect Your Retirement

Silver outperformed stocks by 166.4% during this period. Learn how to add silver to your retirement portfolio with a Silver IRA.

Most helpful for investors with $100k+ in IRA, 401k or retirement accounts

Claim Your Zero-Fee Silver IRA Kit

Data sources: Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED), S&P Dow Jones Indices, LBMA Silver Price

Silver prices based on London Silver Fix. S&P 500 includes dividends reinvested.